Essay: Review of Icons of Life: A Cultural History of Human Embryos

To Lynn M. Morgan, the Mary E. Woolley Professor of Anthropology at Mt. Holyoke College, nothing says ?life? more than a dead embryo. In her easily readable book, Icons of Life: A Cultural History of Human Embryos [3], Morgan brings together cultural phenomena, ethics, and embryology [4] to show that even dead embryos and fetuses have their own stories to tell. As an anthropologist, Morgan is interested in many things, including the science of embryology [4] and its history. But she also wants to know how culture influences our views on embryos and the material practices that accompany their study. Her intent is to establish a relationship between ?specimens collected in the remote past and the contemporary cultural politics of abortion? (p. xiii). The eight chapters in Icons of Life do not provide an exhaustive historical look at early American embryology [4], but they do weave together the Carnegie Institute of Washington Embryology Department [5] (CIWED), its major human embryo collector Franklin Paine Mall [6], and how early twentieth-century science worked. Morgan ably describes the CIWED?s early foray into embryo collecting, but she wants to do more than just describe how embryos made their way to the laboratory. She wants us to ask why it was even possible for such a thing to happen without so much as a fuss being made from the public. This involves looking at culture.